When most leaders talk about workplace culture, they focus on the glossy side: values on a website, the inspiring mission statement, and maybe a few photos from a team-building event. But in reality, culture isn’t what you post on your “About Us” page. It’s the collection of habits, decisions, and everyday behaviors, especially those made when no one is looking, that determine how people experience your workplace.
In this episode of What’s the DEIL?, hosts Shanté and Natalie go beyond the surface. They unpack why “culture” isn’t just a feel-good term, but often the unseen culprit behind workplace investigations. Whether the problem is favoritism, bias, or retaliation, these issues usually don’t come from a single bad day. They grow quietly over time, fed by leadership inaction and tolerated behaviors.
The conversation is a wake-up call: if you’re not paying attention to the day-to-day reality of your culture, you could be setting the stage for your next formal complaint.
When Complaints Aren’t About Just One Thing
A surprising truth emerges from years of investigations—most formal complaints are rarely about an isolated incident. Instead, they’re the visible tip of a much larger iceberg.
Imagine an employee filing a harassment complaint. On paper, it might look like a single event sparked the issue. But as investigators dig deeper, patterns begin to emerge: maybe the same individual has been reported for inappropriate behavior before, and nothing was done. Maybe certain people get away with things others can’t. Maybe leaders have sent signals—subtle or otherwise—that some rules only apply to some people.
This pattern isn’t random. It’s culture. And when left unchecked, it’s only a matter of time before the damage shows up in a formal investigation.
The Slow Decay: Favoritism, Bias, and Leader Friendships
Few things erode trust in an organization faster than the perception of favoritism. It might start small—a manager giving more flexible deadlines to one team member or consistently inviting the same few people to strategic meetings. But over time, employees notice. And they remember.
When bias—conscious or unconscious—seeps into decision-making, the impact multiplies. A leader’s personal friendships with certain employees can also cloud judgment, leading to leniency or special treatment that undermines fairness.
Shanté and Natalie stress that it’s not just the “big” decisions that shape culture. It’s the accumulation of daily choices—who gets the stretch assignment, who gets their ideas heard, who gets the benefit of the doubt. These micro-decisions create the unwritten rules of your workplace.
Why Investigations Can’t Fix Culture
Here’s the hard truth: once an investigation is underway, the damage is already done. The goal of an investigation is to determine facts, not to repair trust or reshape culture. By the time formal action is taken, employees have often endured months—sometimes years—of unhealthy workplace dynamics.
Leaders sometimes treat investigations like a reset button, believing that a fair resolution will “fix” the problem. But without addressing the underlying culture, the same patterns will resurface.
That’s where culture audits come in. Unlike investigations, which are reactive, culture audits are proactive. They allow organizations to assess how policies are applied, how employees experience leadership, and where risks are forming—before those risks turn into complaints.
Retaliation: The Silent Risk
Retaliation is one of the most damaging—and legally dangerous—responses to a workplace complaint. It’s also more common than most leaders think.
Retaliation doesn’t always look like a dramatic firing or demotion. It can be subtle:
-
Excluding someone from meetings they used to attend.
-
Suddenly reassigning them to less desirable work.
-
Overly scrutinizing their performance after they raise a concern.
These actions send a chilling message to other employees: speaking up comes at a cost. The ripple effect is powerful—people stop reporting issues, and problems fester in silence.
Natalie and Shanté emphasize that preventing retaliation isn’t just about compliance with the law—it’s about protecting the integrity of your workplace. Leaders must not only avoid retaliatory actions themselves but actively guard against them within their teams.
Everyday Leadership Signals Matter More Than Policy
Policies are important. They provide clarity and structure. But they’re only as effective as the behavior of the people enforcing them.
When leaders take action—addressing small issues before they escalate—they send a clear signal that standards apply to everyone. When they ignore bad behavior, make excuses for certain employees, or “wait for more evidence” before acting, they send the opposite message.
Shanté and Natalie point out that employees watch what leaders do far more than what they say. A beautifully worded policy in the handbook means little if the reality on the ground is inconsistent.
The Power of a Culture Audit
If investigations are the ambulance at the bottom of the hill, culture audits are the fence at the top. A culture audit examines the lived reality of your organization:
-
Are leaders consistently modeling the values you promote?
-
Are certain employees or departments insulated from accountability?
-
Are policies applied fairly and equitably across the board?
-
Do employees trust the complaint process, or do they see it as futile?
The goal isn’t to assign blame, it’s to identify patterns before they lead to formal action. Done well, a culture audit can:
-
Save money by preventing costly investigations and turnover.
-
Protect morale by addressing small cracks before they widen.
-
Strengthen leadership credibility by showing a commitment to fairness and transparency.
Proactive, Not Performative
In a world where “culture” can become a buzzword, it’s tempting to roll out flashy initiatives that look good in a press release. But culture work isn’t about optics—it’s about impact.
A culture audit, done honestly, might uncover uncomfortable truths. It might require difficult conversations about leadership practices, structural inequities, or communication gaps. But those insights are exactly what make the process valuable.
Performative efforts—like putting “integrity” in your core values without addressing a known pattern of favoritism—only deepen cynicism among employees. Proactive culture work, on the other hand, builds genuine trust.
A Wake-Up Call for Leaders
This episode is more than a discussion—it’s a challenge to leaders at every level. It’s not enough to assume your culture is “fine” because you haven’t had a major complaint lately. In many cases, the absence of complaints is a sign that employees don’t believe raising issues will lead to change.
If you want to lead well, you need to:
-
Look beyond policies and examine day-to-day realities.
-
Recognize patterns early, before they escalate.
-
Be willing to hear uncomfortable feedback.
-
Commit to consistent, fair action—even when it’s inconvenient.
Culture is built in the moments between big decisions. It’s in how you handle the “small” stuff, how you respond to the first sign of trouble, and how you treat people when the stakes are low. Get those moments right, and you’ll prevent many of the crises that land on your desk.
Final Thoughts
Shanté and Natalie’s conversation is a reminder that culture is both the foundation of your workplace and the lens through which every employee experiences it. Ignore it, and you invite patterns that lead to conflict, complaints, and investigations.
But lead it proactively, consistently, and transparently and culture becomes your organization’s greatest asset. It drives trust, fuels performance, and keeps you out of the costly cycle of investigation and repair.
Connect With Us
If you found this discussion compelling, we invite you to connect with us further. Here are some ways to stay in touch:
- Follow Natalie Norfus on LinkedIn
- Follow Shanté Gordon on LinkedIn
- Book a consultation with The Norfus Firm
- Follow What’s the DEIL on Instagram and TikTok
